American College of Attorneys Best of the Bar Award
10.0 Avvo Superb Lawyer Rating
Top 100 Trial Lawyers Award
Orlando Top Lawyers 2012 - 2024
Best Lawyers in America Award
Super Lawyers 2024 Award
Florida Legal Elite Award
Best Lawyers 2024 Award
Orlando Sentinel Best Bets Lawyer Award

What Is Bad Faith Insurance in a Florida Personal Injury Case?

Car accident cases may involve an insurance company who wrongfully denies payment in “bad faith.” In these cases, insurers can be sued for damages over and above the limit stated in the policy.

There are no limits on a bad faith claim—even if the case value is more than the policy coverage limits. It is essential to have experienced legal counsel protecting your rights in these cases.

Speak with an experienced Florida attorney at our firm today.
Call 855-Kramer-Now (855-572-6376)

When insurance providers wrongly deny or delay payment, our attorneys can apply bad faith laws to compel them to pay up to full case value. Florida statutes and common law remedies may also allow our lawyers to impose additional penalties, depending on the case.

If you suspect that you are the victim of car insurance bad faith practices, speak with a TK Law attorney as soon as possible.

Florida’s Bad Faith Insurance Law Protects the Insured

When you purchase an auto insurance policy, you expect to be covered or reimbursed when the unexpected happens. If your insurer does not follow through with the promised coverage and wrongfully refuses to pay a claim, they are acting in bad faith.

To understand “bad faith” one must know what “good faith” is, and what your insurance company’s duties are to you, the policyholder.

Every insurance policy has the inherent covenant of “good faith and fair dealings.” Basically, your insurer has an obligation to

  • treat you fairly and honestly when evaluating the validity of your claim.
  • settle claims against you if it can do so within the coverage limit.

What types of conduct might be bad faith?

  • Failure to pay or settle a claim within policy limits without a reasonable basis
  • Failure to properly and promptly investigate or defend a claim
  • Failure to provide justification for denying a claim
  • Using deceptive practices or intentional misrepresentations to avoid paying claims.
  • Failure to offer the full value of a claim’s worth, or giving an unreasonably low offer to compensate damages

Florida insurance bad faith claims can be generally classified as two types: third party and first party claims.

Third Party Claim – A Claim with the At-fault Driver’s Insurance Company

An example of third party insurance is Bodily Injury (BI) Liability coverage. You purchase this coverage to protect yourself financially in the event you cause an accident that leads to someone else being seriously injured, and they seek damages against you.

Third-party bad faith occurs when your insurer fails to defend a valid claim or refuses to pay a valid claim brought against you by an injured third party—leaving you exposed to a large personal judgment.

When this happens, Florida law allows the injured third party to bring a bad faith cause of action directly against the insurance company. The injured third party is the beneficiary of any successful bad faith claim.

Example of Third Party Bad Faith Insurance

Let us say that you have $200,000 of bodily injury (BI) liability insurance. BI covers you if your negligent driving causes someone else serious harm.

Now, because you ran a stoplight, Mary suffers severe injuries. Mary’s damages are in excess of $1,000,000. Mary and her attorney can look to your BI coverage for up to the policy limit of $200,000, and no more.

So Mary’s attorney sends a demand letter to your insurance company asking for a $200,000 settlement. If your insurer agrees to settles the case, the case is closed and your insurer pays financial compensation to Mary. Your insurer has acted in good faith.

Yet many times another scenario plays out. Quite often, insurance companies fail to pay out claims for the sole reason of saving money. If your insurer does not agree to settlement terms and unreasonably refuses to pay the claim, or otherwise fails to offer the policy limit in a timely manner, the case must go to trial.

Now your insurer has put you, the policyholder at great risk. Litigation ensues. The jury finds you liable and renders a verdict of $1 million. You are now personally responsible for paying the excess $800,000 of the awarded damages.

At this point—once there is a determination of liability and extent of the damages owed—Florida law allows protection for the insured defendant (you) and the injured plaintiff (Mary) through a bad faith lawsuit.

As the defendant, you may assign the bad faith lawsuit against your insurer to Mary. This absolves you from liability for the judgment, and lets Mary sue the insurer for the additional $800,000 – to recover the full amount of her damages – because your insurance company engaged in bad faith insurance practices.

First Party Claim – A Claim with Your Insurance Company.

You purchase Uninsured/Underinsured (UM) coverage to protect yourself if you sustain injuries and damages in an accident. If no other insurance is available or exhausted, you may make a claim against your own UM coverage up to the policy limit.

Example of First Party Bad Faith Insurance

On your way home from work someone T-bones you. You are badly hurt with realistic damages at $80,000. The wrongful driver has no liability insurance, therefore there is nothing to recover. You have $100,000 UM coverage on your own policy, so your attorney files a well-founded claim on your policy for $80,000.

Yet your insurance company drags their feet for months. They finally reject the claim. This contradicts any semblance of “good faith and fair dealings” under the terms of the policy. You may now have a bad faith claim against your own insurance company for breach of contract and failing to live up to the promise of coverage under your UM policy.

When Your Insurance Company Acts in Bad Faith, Call us

Bad faith insurance claims are complicated actions and involve a multitude of issues.

TK Law attorneys understand the concept of bad faith by insurance companies. We are prepared to apply the law and our experience in order to secure additional compensation for our injury clients or quickly settle claims for their full value, not just the policy limit.

Our goal as Orlando personal injury lawyers is to maximize your claim and ensure the insurance company does not wrongfully deny your claim for fair and just compensation.

Speak with an experienced Florida attorney at our firm today.
Call 855-Kramer-Now (855-572-6376)

Free Case Review

All free case evaluations are reviewed by our legal team. For immediate assistance, please call us at 407-834-4847.

Car Accident Law Information


Make Your Best Decision Today


Schedule your case review so we can help you.



During your consultation we’ll review your options and see if we’re a right fit for you.



If we take on your case, you’ll be represented by the best.

Get Your Free Case Evaluation Today

The Orlando divorce lawyers at TK Law are deeply committed to the individuals and families they serve. We are here to help you resolve each legal concern so you can regain control and move forward with your life. You will also have a steadfast, accomplished advocate in your corner to fight for what matters most if a dispute goes to trial.

We know how overwhelming conflict can be and how painful it is to see a marriage end. We will guide you through this difficult process before, during and after your divorce.

Contact our offices today to schedule a confidential consultation with one or our family law attorneys, or call us at 855-572-6376.



Our best awards are
client victories

Roy P.
Mar. 2024
Read More
Gastell and Kayla were awesome! They helped me make it through a very challenging time in my life with kindness and compassion. They were always available to answer my questions and kept me up to date. Their counsel was extremely helpful in aiding a resolution that I am very satisfied with.
Carmen D.
Mar. 2024
Read More
I give this law firm a 5 star. Ray and Janelise helped us with our probate issue and made the process a lot easier for us to finalized all of it. We're very thankful to this law office and recommend them for any legal issues.Thank you Janelisse and Ray and the entire office .
Alysia T.
Jan. 2024
Read More
I am thankful to Janelise and Kayla at TK Law for a fantastic job. Kayla guided me through every step of my divorce process. She is patient, professional, and honest. I highly recommend them!
Chris O.
Dec. 2023
Read More
This was first experience hiring a law firm and I am very happy that I hired TK Law. My attorney Janelise and Paralegal Kayla were kind, knowledgeable and made the process easy. They were quick to respond when I needed revisions to my document and the final outcome was perfect. If I ever need legal help in the future, I will not hesitate to contact TK Law again.

*Top-rating from clients and award publications such as Orlando Weekly, US News & more.​


Schedule Your Case Evaluation

We offer payment plans, accept credit cards, are available for evening appointments and our main office is conveniently located right off of I-4, between 436 and 434. For immediate help call: 407-834-4847.


The information found here is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any situation or individual case. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.


Phone: 407-834-4847
999 Douglas Ave #3333, Altamonte Springs, FL 32714

Service Areas

Orange & Seminole County, Florida.